Pasadena smoke claim resolved through appraisal

A $40,000 gap between the carrier's estimate and the contractor's cleaning scope went to appraisal, and additional funds were awarded.

Total settlement

$71,456.96
Date of loss
January 7, 2025
Cause
Eaton Fire smoke and wind
Location
Pasadena, CA
Resolution
Appraisal

Background

After the Eaton Fire, this Pasadena home had heavy smoke contamination in the structure and contents. The roof also took wind damage during the fire, the roof and exterior were coated in soot, and the solar panel system needed specialized cleaning to restore performance.

Initial claim handling

We opened the claim, coordinated inspections and submitted a photo report and restoration estimate covering the interior, roof surfaces and solar panels. The carrier made an initial dwelling payment, but its estimate was far below the contractor's.

Coverage dispute

A gap of about $40,000 opened up between the two estimates for smoke remediation. The carrier said a third-party vendor would review the scope, but despite ongoing documentation the gap stayed unresolved. To move forward, the claim went to appraisal, the formal dispute process written into most property policies.

Appraisal outcome

Through appraisal the disputed scope and costs were evaluated independently, and additional funds were awarded for dwelling smoke cleaning.

Payments issued

Initial dwelling cleaning$17,571.56
Dwelling cleaning supplement$14,186.56
Hygienist testing$3,590.00
Dwelling cleaning supplement$16,809.12
Contents cleaning$10,886.93
Dwelling cleaning supplement$8,412.79
Total settlement$71,456.96

Every claim is different and no result is guaranteed.

Settlement checks

Initial Dwelling Cleaning Check
Initial Dwelling Cleaning Check
Dwelling Cleaning Supplement Check
Dwelling Cleaning Supplement Check
Hygienist Testing Check
Hygienist Testing Check
Dwelling Cleaning Supplement Check
Dwelling Cleaning Supplement Check
Contents Cleaning Check
Contents Cleaning Check
Dwelling Cleaning Supplement Check
Dwelling Cleaning Supplement Check

Get a second look before you sign.

A free review shows you what the insurer left out, what your policy covers and whether your claim is worth pursuing further.